Xtra Milk

this doesn't have a scent just a cream texture (maybe it's because i'm not used to buying perfumes purely for layering but i cannot see how someone could justify paying for...nothing?)

I legit smell nothing!! I sprayed it for the first time right out of the shower, hoping this could be a go-to skin scent, but it literally smells like nothing. As in, not worth the price at all.... I enjoy it, though. It works if you're okay with spraying something on just for the kick of it, but you might as well just spray yourself with water and sniff your wrist.....

I wasn’t able to truly smell it for a bit, but it smells so fresh and clean with a little musk. very lovely and not overwhelming.

Is a very nice fragrance but to my nose it smells almost identical to 11 11. I do prefer this one over 11 11

Realllly like this. Tested next to Rosie Jane and I can definitely smell this… so beautiful, light & fluffy! RJ… not so much.

i really really wanted to love this one. it goes kind of sour on me after like 3 minutes though

I smell baby wipes. It's a nice, clean smell.

I bought this scent in the winter. Mistake. It's powerful in the summer months (canada). I love it so much on my clothes. I wish I could wear it year round.

Powdery white musk with a punch of amber. Something about it gives me a headache. Borders on too strong for me, which is surprising because usually I can’t smell musks well.

In theory this is an amazing, intimate, close to your lover scent. But I have tried and tried and I never got to smell anything. I tried leaving it for a while, still nothing. Let it settle on skin for ages, nothing. Everytime I thought I maybe caught a whiff of something, I think I was imagining it.

After almost a year, I can finally smell it. The times I sprayed my sample before I actually smelled nothing! Now I'm getting a scent like skin and clean laundry? I wore it to bed last night, I liked at first then somehow it was strong and actually almost made me nauseous don't ask me how because I have no idea. How can a scent be nothing and then too much? So strange...

I love skin scents, and this is a wonderful fragrance, but just don’t agree with it smelling close to nothing- with the few notes it does a lot with it, I really love this scent and feel it is lovely alone and a fabulous first layer, my favorite being Leila Lou by Rosie Jane

I have sprayed Xtra Milk in a few different places trying to see how it responds to my skin, and each time it has opened up with warm, dusty paper notes, like thumbing through a paperback book in a hot car. It does have a tendency to be anosmic because of its composition, but I can pick up the creamy, sweet aroma if I spray it in the crook of my elbow. For the price, there are more compelling “warm clean skin” fragrances (I’m a Glossier You Doux fan), but I do really like the simplicity of Xtra Milk. It’s very versatile, and it has so much potential for layering. Update: I gave my bottle to the person I had smelled it on originally. It just wasn’t doing enough for me.

The musk in this is way too harsh. Almost has a faint bug spray/lavender vibe to it which I can’t vibe with.

I really wanted to love this. Being a barista, I smell milk often. Aside from coffee, it's probably in my top 2 smells just on, like, a frequency basis. I am still on the hunt for the perfect lactonic fragrance, and this is unfortunately not it. You spray it on and immediately it wanders off, a cloud in the distance, the hint of a fragrance that might have been there at some point but left. And the scent that is there isn't even lactonic, it's just vaguely musky. With a name like XTRA MILK, you'd expect it to be loud and milky. It is a musky whimper.

This is the first perfume that I like enough to own. Not overpowering or headache enducing, just comforting smell that you can't get sick of. I sampled this in store so many times before buying. Initially it smells like alcohol but after a while it becomes more potent, clinging to clothing for weeks after. The bottle I bought though is the opposite-- has a sharp opening but fades almost instantly. I'm not sure if its because its newer or what but the silliage and longevity is disapointing. Everyone I share this perfume with can smell it though so I don't get how so many people are anosmic to it.

This smells like bug spray, I reached for an alcohol pad to wipe it off almost immediately after attacking my skin with it but the lasting power is so inexistent that by the time I was about to wipe it off it was already gone, and that was my favorite part about the fragrance. The only emotion this evoked in me was guilt because it suddenly made me feel like the roach I killed earlier in the day with Ray.

Not unpleasant but absolutely pleasureless. Upsettingly, potently featureless and not in an interesting posthuman replicant way. This is the scent you hallucinate when you stick googly eyes on your pet rock and start to believe that it's alive and it loves you. The scent of the little sterile igloo Julianne Moore lives in at the end of the film 'Safe'. The scent of being on SSRIs for a decade and attempting to remember how hugging your mother used to feel. Xtra Milk is the scent of telling yourself you are loved but not quite believing it. Does not smell like milk.

This was gifted me and was a blind buy from what I was told. I sprayed it on and I was immediately transported to Dollar Tree. It smells like the blast of a certain smell you get when you walk into that store. I personally do not want to smell like the Dollar Tree. I ran my wrist under my husband's nose to get his opinion and he said "I smell nothing." From many of the reviews, he is in the majority.

I absolutely love this smell but it’s super subtle and the scent disappears right after first spray! So disappointing, xtra nothing ….. Dedcool please fix this. Do we need an Xtra Xtra milk? Needs that staying power!!

after a while i’ve officially gained the powers to be able to smell this- after it almost always smelling like nothing. it’s still subtle but it lasts surprisingly long on clothes. i really love this, just too bad my samples almost gone. still can’t decide whether i would prefer to buy mochi milk

definitely anosmic, if youre lucky it might smell a bit like glossier you, but if your like me it could also start smelling a little bitter and industrial after a minute

Ok so I was really excited to try this because I’d seen all of the great reviews. So upon opening I got a musk that kind of reminds me of Light Blue from Dolce and Gabbana (which I love), but it then has this almost metallic sharpness that overpowers it completely. It honestly smells like a clean musk mixed with ants. Maybe that’s insane but that’s exactly what I’m getting. I’ll get whiffs of it and I’ll only really pick up a faint smell and it is a very light musk but then the metallic smell overpowers. I feel like it’s THIS close to being a favorite scent if it just didn’t have that sharp metallic note!

I first got this fragrance because one of my friends put it on in her room an hour before I came over and I could not stop smelling how good it was. When I bought my first bottle I was initially disappointed as I didn’t get a lot of strength from it. But what made me absolutely love it was how I changed using it! I essentially use it as a primer for my other fragrances and I’ve noticed my fragrances I put on top last longer and seem to project better with this added underneath. It mixes well with essentially almost all fragrances I own. Even after a full 12 hour shift in the hospital I have coworkers asking me how I still smell so good!

It sometimes blends in completely and sometimes smells so strongly. It’s warm and not like a perfume, it’s like someone who smells good and you want to be around them because it’s comfortable and a little bit sensual. Not sexy, not heady like desire, very unobtrusive and in the body, just sensual and inviting

Sadly I am fully anosmic to this one and to the other milk from dedcool too.. Maybe I get a hint of bergamot, but that's it. Fortunately, these are the only perfumes I experienced this (afaik).

soapy and clean! not worth a full bottle for me especially since my boyfriend is anosmic to it

I can smell it immediately after spraying it and then it dries down to nothing. Definitely not worth purchasing a full size. I agree with those saying it smells like skin fresh out of the shower but only for the first few minutes because any longer and it’s faded away completely. I also get hints of cardboard? It’s odd

Well, I finally found the only perfume I am fully anosmic to.

This smells like elmers glue.